Following yesterday’s bombshell news that Queen Anne is to leave the Cunard fleet, I have been bombarded with questions. The response across Substack, YouTube and ChrisCunard.com has been one of shock, amazement and confusion.

Sure, Queen Anne has had her fair share of critics since entering service. These critics point to a far too modern take on the Cunard experience, as the main reason for her apparent failure within the Cunard family.
And then there are her supporters. People like me, who saw the ship for what she was. An attempt to broaden the Cunard experience through a new design that was clearly aimed at a younger traveller who didn’t have decades of experience with the Cunard of days gone by.
Looking at questions I’ve received in the last 24 hours, the dominant theme is: how is it possible that a half billion euro cruise ship could outstay its welcome at its foundation cruise line, in such a staggeringly short period of time?
The answer to that question currently eludes me. And everyone else it seems, as the media response has so far been unable to unravel the tangled web that sits behind such a dramatic move.

It seems that most of my questions align with questions being asked across cruise forms, travel journalists and social media. So with that in mind, I’ve spent the morning looking at the words of Carnival UK, P&O Cruises and Cunard president Paul Ludlow, to try and work out what’s going on…
“These decisions reflect a careful, long-term view of our portfolio and where the individual strengths of each ship can best support guest demand and the future direction of our two cruise lines.”
Queen Anne is 29 months old at the time of this announcement. She will be less than 5 years old when she moves to P&O Cruises. How could the ship have failed in such a short period of time, to justify such an early departure? And were there no opportunities to adjust the strategy and product offered aboard this ship to save her place as Cunard’s 249th vessel?
I look to the mountains of customer feedback, shared on forums like Cruise Critic and across the comments sections of multiple other platforms.
I can’t help but feel that there were many opportunities to tweak Queen Anne, to bring it more in line with the rest of the Cunard fleet. This could have been done without compromising the ‘new’ and ‘modern’ aspect the designers were seeking.
Ideas that come to mind include bringing more historic and maritime imagery into the public spaces, improving the story telling linked with several new spaces (such as the Bright Lights Society), and relocating iconic Cunard events such as afternoon tea from the smaller Queens Room to a more spacious venue, like the Britannia Restaurant, to avoid queues.
Following on from that, the next question is: what is the future direction of the two cruise lines?
The commentary so far has been fairly vague as to what Cunard’s future looks like, other than the fact that it will revert to having just three ships. When looking ahead to 2029, Cunard will be in a position where its newest ship, the 2010 Queen Elizabeth, will have passed its midlife mark.
This means that the Cunard fleet of Three Queens will be an ageing fleet. That isn’t a great position for the brand to be in as maintenance costs increase and passengers demand modern amenities.
“Queen Anne was created as a bold and contemporary expression of Cunard, combining the brand’s hallmark service and sense of occasion with modern design, an extensive choice of dining and entertainment, and highly flexible public spaces.”
Cunard’s hallmark service and sense of occasion have always been a result of the highly attentive crew, made possible thanks to an investment in the humans who deliver the service. From Sagafjord to Sea Goddess I, QE2 to Caronia, and Queen Mary 2, regardless of the ship, the sense of occasion was created by the people working aboard.
Many critics point to Queen Anne’s design as her failing. But her fixtures and fittings are not a barrier to creating a sense of occasion.
To be clear, I think the officers and crew aboard Queen Anne are delivering an incredible service. I know first hand that they genuinely care about the ship, the brand and the passengers.

Having worked with the team at the shipyard, and also while lecturing aboard the ship (and sailing aboard three times now) there is no doubt in my mind that the crew are proud of their ship; from the Captain to the Hotel General Manager to restaurant staff to engineers to cleaners.
But, room service fees for Britannia guests, reduction in evening formality, and reduced food quality (as mentioned across hundreds of Cruise Critic and Trip Advisor reviews) have impacted the sense of occasion that Cunard passengers are looking for.
“Queen Anne has established a special place within the Cunard fleet and she has an exciting programme ahead, including a central role in the Four Queens celebration in Liverpool in May 2028 and her final World Voyage as a Cunard ship in January ‘29. We will ensure that the seasons ahead are a fitting celebration of her time as a Cunard Queen.”
I am a fan of Queen Anne, as I’ve said in many past articles and YouTube videos, but like so many online observers I do have to wonder… If the ship is to be retired from Cunard in under 5 years, to what extent has she achieved a special place within the fleet?
“At the same time, the change will give Cunard a more closely unified fleet centred on Queen Mary 2, Queen Victoria and Queen Elizabeth. Each has a deeply established identity and embodies the timeless style, heritage and sense of occasion that guests around the world most closely associate with Cunard.”
Not withstanding the unique design of Queen Mary 2, I agree that the QM2, Queen Victoria and Queen Elizabeth are closer aligned in their onboard product offering.
But this was true before Queen Anne was ordered, built, fitted out and delivered. It has also been true over the past two years of Queen Anne’s service. Yet nothing material has been done to better align Queen Anne to the rest of the fleet. This is a point that is puzzling many of you, and rightly so.
So what does this all mean?
Presumably, as they are moving the ship, there are very good reasons for it. Carnival Corp. is the largest operator of cruise ships in the world. Over the decades they have shown themselves to be resilient, savvy and a market leader in the industry.
But that doesn’t stop us from asking questions, especially when a Cunard Queen is flagged for withdrawal in such an unprecedented manner.
This news is so fresh, it is unlikely that any further clarity around the decision will come any time soon, at least until the dust settles.
Just to close off, I am personally disappointed to see Queen Anne leave the fleet. I feel for the officers and crew on board. I also feel for the people shoreside who have had to make such hard decisions, as I know the team at Cunard were very passionate about this ship.
And I remain hopeful for the future of Cunard. It has long been my opinion that Cunard would be better served by a fleet of smaller, boutique cruise ships to operate alongside QM2. Perhaps a Pinnacle-class Cunard ship with 3,000+ passengers was always doomed to fail.
If you have questions about the Queen Anne’s retirement that you’d like to share, please do so below. Hopefully, we will be able to provide some answers in due course.




Chris, I think this from a business perspective makes sense. It was clear Cunard were not successful in running a 4 ship fleet. They tried QE in Australia but from what I heard it was not making good returns as was much discounting. They tried having it year round in US but same issue in the Caribbean. They were sending back to retry fly - sail in the Med but think the reality is that only the no fly cruises with mostly UK guests works for good returns. They can’t do that with 4 ships. Also hopefully they will stop trying to chase a different audience to full 4 ships and focus on in making Cunard what makes it different- and hopefully take a leaf from HAl and Celebrity and invest in getting cabins and bathrooms all up to date etc
While I too am disappointed to see the fleet reduced in size, I think QA was a bold gamble that Cunard / Carnival were willing to take, but they recognized that she was a bit of an outlier in the Cunard experience. It does bother me that the youngest ship of the 3 remaining will be 19 years old, with no clear plan to revitalize the fleet (other than by refits) with new builds. I would love to see a couple of more boutique ships, using something like the Sagafjord/Vistafjord class as a blueprint, join the fleet.